Call Us
470-467-2200
Get Free Consult
Get Free Consult
by The Stoddard Firm - April 17th, 2025
Understanding a preponderance of evidence examples can significantly affect a personal injury claim’s success. Imagine being injured in a car accident due to someone else’s negligence. When seeking compensation, the outcome depends on proving the case with stronger evidence than the opposing party. This standard—the preponderance of evidence—can be the key factor in awarding compensation. Unlike criminal cases, where proof “beyond a reasonable doubt” is necessary, the preponderance of evidence focuses on which side presents a more convincing argument.
This guide explains the concept of preponderance of evidence, how it impacts personal injury claims, and how The Stoddard Firm can help you gather the evidence needed to secure the compensation you deserve.
The preponderance of evidence is a legal standard used in civil cases to decide which side’s argument is more convincing. Picture a scale. If the evidence tips slightly in one direction—by just over 50%—that side wins. Unlike in criminal cases, where proof must eliminate reasonable doubt, civil cases focus on probabilities rather than certainties.
This concept – the preponderance of the evidence – impacts the outcome of many civil cases, determining which party’s argument carries more weight to resolve disputes fairly. Evidence in personal injury cases can include witness testimonies, documents, photographs, and expert opinions. By meeting this standard, plaintiffs demonstrate that the defendant is more likely than not responsible for their injuries. A strong preponderance of evidence example would include multiple sources of proof supporting the claim, such as physical evidence and corroborating testimony, but also some testimony that does not support the claim. In such an example, the evidence is conflicting and the fact-finder might have some doubts, but the fact-finder is leaning towards believing one explanation over another.
A personal injury case is civil, meaning the preponderance of evidence standard applies. Instead of proving guilt, plaintiffs must demonstrate that the defendant is more likely than not responsible for their injuries. For example, in a natural gas explosion case, showing that a maintenance worker had a habit of failing to cap gas lines combined with testimony from a co-worker that the co-worker does not remember anyone transporting gas line caps from the truck to the jobsite, and combined with the a gas explosion occurring may satisfy the requirement, even if the maintenance worker with the habit of failing to cap gas lines testifies that he did cap the gas line at issue.
Criminal cases, by contrast, require conviction beyond a reasonable doubt. This strict standard is reserved for cases involving loss of liberty or significant consequences, such as jail time. This distinction is crucial for injury victims—winning a personal injury case does not require proving absolute fault, only that the defendant is more likely than not responsible.
Successfully meeting the preponderance standard can directly influence the success of your injury claim. Strong documentation plays a pivotal role when presenting a preponderance of evidence example . Building strong evidence, such as medical records or surveillance footage, strengthens your claim and improves your chance of receiving compensation.
Examples might include clear medical documentation linking your injuries to the accident, photographs or videos showing hazardous conditions at the accident scene, eyewitness statements supporting your version of events, and expert opinions confirming causation and the extent of damages.
When determining negligence in various types of personal injury cases, preponderance of evidence plays a vital role. Below are common scenarios where this legal standard comes into play.
Truck accidents often involve complex liability issues. Evidence can include maintenance logs or GPS reports to prove that the driver or company failed to follow safety standards. For instance, dashcam footage showing a truck swerving before a collision may meet the standard to hold the trucking company accountable.
Brain injury lawsuits typically depend on expert opinion and medical examinations to determine causation. Consider the scenario of hitting your head in a car accident—the negligence of the defendant could be established with medical records indicating your brain injury resulted from the collision caused by their negligent driving.
Pedestrian injury cases often require evidence such as traffic camera footage, witness statements, or accident reconstruction. For example, if a pedestrian is hit at a crosswalk and the driver fails to stop at a red light, video evidence and traffic reports may showcase a preponderance of evidence.
It’s important to gather all relevant evidence before filing a personal injury case, including insurance details, medical records, and witness statements, to strengthen your case.
Proving your claim requires gathering compelling, credible evidence. Here are steps to meet the preponderance of evidence standard:
Collect police reports, witness testimony, and medical records. These form a solid basis for your case, allowing all details needed to be preserved and available for effective presentation before the court or in settlement discussions.
Use photos of injuries or accident scenes and any available video footage to illustrate your claims.
Have specialists, such as doctors or accident reconstruction experts, testify on causation and damages.
Keep a journal documenting pain, suffering, and recovery to show the injury’s impact on your life.
Even with robust evidence, achieving a preponderance of evidence can be challenging. Common hurdles include:
At The Stoddard Firm , we specialize in personal injury cases and know how to gather and present evidence to effectively meet the preponderance standard. Whether you’ve been injured in a truck accident, as a pedestrian, or due to negligence, our team has the expertise to build a strong case.
Here’s what sets us apart:
Contact us today at 470-467-2200 to schedule your free consultation
A dedicated, ethical advocate who takes on major corporations and global insurers with virtually unlimited resources. Known for high-profile cases featured on Courtroom Viewing Network, this attorney is also a sought-after legal educator, teaching at seminars for top bar associations. Trusted by clients and media alike, they work tirelessly to secure justice and deliver results.
Member of the Atlanta Bar Association, the Georgia Bar Association, and the Georgia Trial Lawyers Association
Licensed in Georgia since: 2008
Education: University of Georgia School of Law
Personal injury compensation enables an injured individual to regain the same quality of life they had before the incident. This may entail funds for modifying a home for wheelchair accessibility or offering vocational training for those unable to return to their previous job. It is crucial for compensation to cover lost earnings and cover both past and anticipated medical costs.
We conduct interviews with colleagues, consult with attending healthcare professionals, and engage specialists to ensure we secure comprehensive compensation that aids our clients in re-establishing their life trajectories.
When deciding to hire an Atlanta personal injury lawyer, you need to consider:
1. Who’s at Fault
If you’re in an accident and it’s unclear who’s responsible, seeking advice from an attorney is wise. Insurance companies may attempt to attribute damages to you in such scenarios. An attorney can shield you from counterclaims and cross-claims, safeguarding your rights.
2. The Severity of Injuries Sustained
When facing a lifetime of pain, suffering, and mounting bills, taking chances is not an option. A personal injury attorney is entrusted with averting lifelong financial strain.
3. If You’re Facing Insurance Company Denial or Delay
The intricate laws and procedures surrounding personal injury claims are areas where insurance companies capitalize on individuals’ lack of expertise. A lawyer can provide invaluable assistance in this regard.
It’s possible but not necessarily probable and will likely depend on whether you want your case to go to trial. The majority of cases end in a settlement. Going to trial typically occurs when there are intricate, contentious matters regarding the accident’s cause or the severity of your injuries. Occasionally, defendants may simply be unyielding and unwilling to settle or you may just want more than the insurer believes is reasonable.
It shouldn’t be a shock if your attorney diligently pursues a settlement while also readying your witnesses for trial. A proficient lawyer must be equipped for any scenario. Demonstrating to the opposing party that we’re gearing up for a trial indicates that we’re resolute and not inclined to back down.
Determining all potential parties who could be held liable for a personal injury involves a thorough investigation of various factors. If someone else neglected to exercise reasonable care, they can be held accountable for the resulting injuries, as outlined in Title 51 of Georgia Code of Laws or as outlined in Georgia’s common law.
The individual directly involved in the accident may not be the sole party at fault. For instance, in the case of a drunk driving accident, while the driver may bear responsibility, the person who knowingly provided additional alcohol to an obviously intoxicated individual could also be deemed liable. In other circumstances, an at fault party’s employer is responsible for its employees actions.
Following a personal injury accident, there are critical steps you should take. First and foremost, seek prompt medical attention. Visit the emergency room or call for an ambulance at the accident site. Any delay in receiving medical care could impact your health and the outcome of your personal injury case.
Refrain from discussing your case with the insurance company representing the at-fault party. They may deny your settlement or offer a significantly lower amount than you deserve.
Additionally, it’s crucial for both you and your personal injury attorney to gather as much evidence and documentation as possible. This is vital in establishing that your injuries resulted from someone else’s negligence. Make an effort to collect records and documents related to your case, including medical records, police reports, photographs, witness contact information, and similar items. Once you’ve received medical attention, contact The Stoddard Firm.
Do not say anything! If an insurance company contacts you, refrain from providing any information until you have consulted with your attorney. Insurance companies typically contact accident victims in an attempt to elicit a statement about the incident, which they may use to devalue the settlement.
While you may eventually need to converse with them, seeking guidance from a seasoned legal team is crucial. They will provide clear instructions on what you should and should not disclose to protect the value of your case.
If you or a loved one has been injured due to someone else’s negligence, we’re here to help. Fill out the form below, and one of our experienced Atlanta personal injury attorneys will contact you shortly to discuss your case. Call us 678-RESULTS.
Your information will remain confidential and used solely to contact you about your case.
This firm is the best in Atlanta, simple as that.
Matthew Stoddard and his staff are wonderful people. This law firm is a no complication type of place. They always answer the phone without the hassle of going through 30 different people and always return emails just as quick as they are received. Thank you gentlemen for everything y’all do.
I went through one of the worst times of my life. When I decided to reach out to Matt it was one of the best decisions I have ever made. He really is a genuine guy who cares about his clients. He worked hard for me and my family for 2 years until we were awarded a settlement we felt deserving! I could not recommend a better guy for your legal services!
Attorney Matthew Stoddard and his staff are awesome professionals. I contacted them with a problem, in my opinion he went above and beyond to assist me. He showed understanding and care and exceeded my expectations.
The Stoddard Firm did an excellent job in representing me in my case ! They went far and beyond to help me, even driving 4 hours to meet me multiple times as a client!!! I honestly felt like I was a member of their legal team and would recommend them to anyone in need of a great lawyer!!!
This page has been written, edited, and reviewed by a team of legal writers following our comprehensive editorial guidelines. This page was revised and approved by Attorney Matthew B. Stoddard, who has more than 16 years of legal experience as a personal injury attorney.
The last few years of amendments to Georgia’s gun laws have expanded the places where residents can carry...
Suffering a back injury at work could mean serious pain, debilitation, and significant time off the job. Wi...
Punitive damages are an additional sum that a civil court may order a negligent party to pay, on top of the...
Losing a loved one is devastating. We fight for justice and compensation, offering compassionate, experienced wrongful death representation during your toughest times.
Car accidents can change lives in an instant. We fight for your recovery and compensation, ensuring your future is protected after a crash.
Truck accidents often cause severe injuries. We hold negligent drivers and companies accountable, fighting for the justice you deserve.
Injured on someone else’s property? We help you navigate premises liability claims, ensuring negligent owners are held responsible.
Defective products can cause serious harm. We stand with you to hold manufacturers accountable and secure the compensation you need.
Survivors of sexual assault and trafficking deserve justice. We provide compassionate legal support to help you reclaim your life.
Construction sites are dangerous. If you’ve been injured, we fight to ensure you receive fair compensation for your injuries and losses.
Motorcycle accidents can be life-altering. We advocate for riders, ensuring negligent drivers are held accountable for your injuries.
Burn injuries cause immense pain and long-term challenges. We fight for your recovery and the compensation needed to rebuild your life.
Injured due to poor security? We hold property owners accountable, ensuring you receive justice for their negligence.
Brain injuries can have lifelong impacts. We fight for your future, securing compensation for medical care, lost wages, and more.
If you or a loved one has been injured due to someone else’s negligence, we’re here to help. Fill out the form below, and one of our experienced Atlanta personal injury attorneys will contact you shortly to discuss your case. Call us 678-RESULTS.
Your information will remain confidential and used solely to contact you about your case.
Message Us 
Call Us