Thrifty Car Rental is one of lower-end brands owned by the vehicle rental corporation, Hertz. As with any rental brand, Thrifty’s rental cars sometimes end up at fault in accidents. And, as with any rental brand, the question of who covers the cost of these accidents isn’t always well-planned in advance.
Below, we’ll go over some of the legal challenges of rental car accidents, reasons you might have a case against Thrifty Car Rental, and some other possible ways of covering your losses after a Thrifty Car Rental accident. If at any time you would prefer to speak directly with a lawyer who handles rental car accidents in the Atlanta area, feel free to reach out by phone or chat.
Most companies (and individuals, for that matter) are legally responsible for accidents caused by vehicles they own. It doesn’t matter whether the owner did anything wrong. A company might hire a qualified professional driver, or an individual might loan a car to a trusted friend, with no reason to believe that they pose a danger to anyone on the roads. Yet if that driver does cause an accident, the damages are still the owner’s responsibility.
The reason for this is that auto insurance policies are more closely tied to a particular vehicle than a particular driver, so it’s considered the owner’s duty to either maintain liability insurance on their vehicle, or keep it off the roads. In cases involving motorcycle accidents in Atlanta, it’s crucial to consult a skilled motorcycle accident lawyer in Atlanta to protect your legal rights and seek compensation for your injuries.
Car rental companies like Thrifty are an exception to this rule. Under the Graves Amendment, rental companies are not responsible for insuring the vehicles they own while they’re in the hands of a renter. Technically, rental companies are supposed to make sure their renters have insurance, but there is no real consequence for failing to do so.
Basically, when someone causes and accident with a rental car, the law treats the at-fault driver as if they, instead of the rental company, were the car’s owner.
This does not mean, however, that there’s never a good, legally sound reason to sue Thrifty Car Rental or brands like it. Reasons can exist. Ownership of an at-fault vehicle just isn’t one of them, at least, not on its own.
Thankfully for accident victims, the Graves Amendment is not a free pass for car rental companies to endanger the public however they want with no accountability. Even though Thrifty is excused from the usual financial responsibilities of vehicle ownership, it can still be held liable if its own behavior contributes to an accident.
Some of the most common ways car rental companies cause accidents and open themselves up to lawsuits include:
Car rental companies choosing to prioritize closing a sale over protecting public safety is a serious and common problem. Performing maintenance on vehicles costs money and takes the vehicle out of rotation, which loses the company more money. And because renters typically take on more liability than the rental company, there’s very little incentive for the company to turn away a potential customer.
In 2020, a woman accused Thrifty of contributing to injuries she had sustained during a high-speed chase in Charleston County, South Carolina, some years earlier. She was a passenger in a Thrifty vehicle, when the driver refused a traffic stop and fled police at speeds reaching 120 miles per hour. The chase ended with the car crashing into a wooded area and catching on fire. The woman argued that Thrifty was responsible, because it had allowed the driver to rent the vehicle using someone else’s ID.
The same year as the woman’s complaint, another driver using a Thrifty vehicle crashed into a Mercedes dealership in Bradford, England, while participating in an illegal racing event. That driver was also unlicensed.
As similar as those two incidents seem, however, there’s one vital difference: the driver in Bradford did not rent the Thrifty vehicle directly. A woman he knew apparently rented and allowed him to borrow it, knowing that he was not included on the rental agreement.
That kind of detail can make the difference between liability or no liability for a company like Thrifty. Car rental companies have a duty to respond to warning signs about renters that fall into their laps — such as a renter not having their own driver’s license — but they are not responsible for proactively vetting customers or reading their minds.
If you’re not sure whether Thrifty had an obligation to help prevent your accident, a lawyer can help you pin down these distinctions.
It’s standard practice in the car rental industry to offer a few different forms of optional coverage, which renters can add onto their contracts for an extra fee.
From the perspective of someone injured by a Thrifty renter, the most important of these options is what Thrifty calls a Liability Insurance Supplement (LIS). This kind of policy goes by different names at different companies, but the concept remains the same.
If a renter purchases an LIS, it means the rental company is assuming responsibility for the harm the driver might cause to others while operating the vehicle, with certain caveats.
Thrifty’s LIS terms are more favorable to victims than most. The dollar limit on the coverage is a full $1 million, and there’s no requirement for the victim or renter to exhaust other possible sources of coverage before turning to Thrifty.
However, virtually all LIS-type policies share one serious drawback. They’re void if the renter has violated any part of the rental agreement. Violating the rental agreement might mean allowing an unapproved driver behind the wheel, driving drunk, or even something that has nothing to do with the accident at all, such as smoking inside the vehicle.
Some rental agreements are so meticulously strict that it’s practically impossible to use the vehicle, let alone crash it, without giving the rental company a reason to deny coverage.
Thankfully, there are limits to the coverage exclusions courts will actually uphold, so it’s worth checking with a lawyer, even if Thrifty has already told you that the at-fault driver’s LIS is void.
When a big brand name like Thrifty/Hertz is connected with an incident that injured you through no fault of your own, it’s natural to hope for that particular company to end up footing the bill. Large companies have the ability to pay for fair settlements. They have entire departments dedicated to handling legal matters as a part of everyday business. They wield enormous power over the safety of thousands of people, not just those involved in one particular accident, and that power should come with accountability.
It’s important to recognize, however, that your options for covering your losses aren’t necessarily limited to suing Thrifty, suing an individual driver who may not be able to afford it, or eating the cost yourself.
In most rental car accidents, there are more parties involved than just the drivers and rental company — and some of them are similarly large and powerful companies.
If it turns out that Thrifty isn’t legally responsible for your accident, either as a negligent party or as an insurer, you may be able to collect compensation from:
It’s also important to remember that each of these companies exists to make a profit. Just because a company has sold you or the at-fault driver a promise of coverage does not mean that it will fulfill that promise voluntarily. Most insurers will try to lowball victims if they can, even at the best of times. In a situation with multiple possible insurers, it’s especially common for each one to try to pass the responsibility to the others, regardless of what the law or the policies say.
Working with a lawyer can help you avoid the runaround, figure out who’s really responsible for compensating you, and hold them to it.
There are a few things you’ll need to do immediately after any serious car accident in Georgia, in order to stay on the right side of the law, protect yourself physically, and set yourself up for the best chance at a fair settlement.
If you initially treat your accident with a Thrifty car the same as you would any other wreck, you’re already off to a good start, but if you’re up to it, you can also ask a few extra questions about the car’s ownership and possible insurers.
For safety and the smoothest path forward, follow these steps:
The Stoddard Firm has experienced professionals who know traffic law, insurance law, personal injury law, and wrongful death law inside and out. We understand how complex rental car accident cases can be and how to handle them.
We’ll investigate the cause of the accident and the terms of all relevant contracts, to optimize our strategy and get you the best settlement. Our top priority is helping our clients recover from their ordeals with all possible support, peace, and comfort. To that end, we’ll work closely with you to take an inventory of the damages to your finances, health, and quality of life, to help determine what full, fair compensation truly means in your case.
To get started discussing your options with a rental car accident lawyer in the Atlanta area, reach out at 678-RESULTS or through our online chat function for a free consultation.
Matt Stoddard is a professional, hardworking, ethical advocate. He routinely faces some of the nation’s largest companies and some of the world’s largest insurers – opponents who have virtually unlimited resources. In these circumstances, Mr. Stoddard is comfortable. Mr. Stoddard provides his strongest efforts to his clients, and he devotes the firm’s significant financial resources to presenting the strongest case possible on their behalf. Matt understands that his clients must put their trust in him. That trust creates an obligation for Matt to work tirelessly on their behalf, and Matt Stoddard does not take that obligation lightly. [ Attorney Bio ]
Tell us about your concern and request a free, no obligation, confidential legal consultation.
After a serious car accident, a survivor usually asks themselves several questions in quick succession. Am I going to be okay? Will everyone else be okay? Was it my fault? What am I going to miss out on? How will I pay for medical care and other expenses? When the answer to the first two questions is “yes,” survivors can jump right into figuring out responsibility and how to m...
