Negligent Security in Apartment Complexes Owned and Managed By JAMCO
When selecting an apartment, most renters take into account factors like price, location, size, and amenities. Depending on personal circumstances like credit rating, many must also consider their likelihood of being accepted. For some, the approachability of the on-site management is an important consideration, but most people don’t give much thought to who actually owns and manages the property, if it’s not someone they’ll interact with on a daily basis.
Residential landlords come in all sizes and sorts, from the local couple with a guesthouse to rent, to large companies with expansive catalogues of multi-family residences. In some complexes, typically condominiums, different units within the same building may even have completely separate ownership arrangements.
In some ways, a larger company might seem like the safer bet when selecting a landlord. After all, a business that exists to manage residential properties ought to be well-informed on landlords’ legal responsibilities to their tenants, and have the budget and policies in place to fulfill those responsibilities.
Unfortunately, it doesn’t always work out that way. Large, wealthy companies do not have the excuse of ignorance or insolvency that the couple with the guesthouse might if they fail to meet their obligations, yet they have an incentive to pad their profits by skimping on security precautions that are vital to their tenants’ safety.
JAMCO Properties, Inc. is one of the larger residential property management companies, currently operating in the Atlanta area, the Jonesboro area, and the surrounding counties including Clayton and DeKalb. Companies like JAMCO know that tenants won’t quietly accept being denied water or electricity, but what about property security? Well, the law requires landlords to protect tenants and guests from known threats, including criminal violence, and JAMCO for one has already run afoul of Georgia’s courts for its negligent security practices.
If you’ve been a victim of negligent security conditions on a JAMCO property, or anywhere else for that matter, the Stoddard Firm may be able to help.
The Bradford Ridge Case
JAMCO Properties, Inc. came under scrutiny in 2015, when a man was shot in the course of a home robbery and later died in the parking lot of his apartment complex, the JAMCO-owned Bradford Ridge Apartment Homes. In itself, the incident might seem unremarkable, albeit tragic, but it’s legally significant precisely because of how commonplace such tragedies appear to be on JAMCO properties.
Just two years earlier at the same complex, a 13-year-old boy was shot by an armed robber in front of his sister’s apartment. According to witnesses, two men drove up to the front of the apartment and demanded the keys to the sister’s truck. She complied, but when the truck wouldn’t start immediately, one of them became agitated and began firing a shotgun at the brother and sister. They ran, but the brother was hit and died in his sister’s arms. Both robbers fled the scene, leaving the truck behind.
The first shooting might not have been foreseeable, but it should have alerted JAMCO to the threat of robbery-motivated gun violence on and around the property. Because of JAMCO’s failure to respond with adequate security measures, the second victim’s family was able to sue the company successfully for $10 million dollars in damages.
There May Be A Similar Pattern On Other JAMCO Properties
Unfortunately for everyone living in JAMCO-owned complexes, the company’s security issues may not be limited to a single property. As one example, Laurel Pointe, another JAMCO property directly across the street from Bradford Ridge, has a similar crime pattern of robbery-motivated shootings. In fact, it was testimony on the unsafe conditions from residents of both complexes that contributed to the ruling against JAMCO in the Bradford Ridge case.
Nor are these incidents endemic to a particular area where JAMCO happens to own property. Crime commonly clusters around particular properties rather than general areas, based on where management is most welcoming or indifferent to it, and this is exactly what seems to be happening at JAMCO complexes across DeKalb, Clayton, and South Fulton.
Stratford Arms Apartments, another complex owned by JAMCO, suffered three arson attempts in 2013 before a suspect was arrested. The following year, a man and woman were shot in yet another JAMCO-owned apartment complex, the Woods at Southlake. The man and woman were both hospitalized, and the perpetrator was never caught. Stratford Arms and the Woods at Southlake are both about three miles from Bradford Ridge, already far enough for a significant difference in crime patterns, but some even more problematic JAMCO properties are much farther removed, most notably Aspen Pointe.
Some JAMCO Properties Have an Even Worse Criminal History Than Bradford Ridge
JAMCO’s Aspen Pointe apartment complex lies some 35 miles north of Laurel Pointe and Bradford Ridge, and it has also been the site of armed robberies, burglaries, rape, and murder. Back in 2009, a serial armed robber was apprehended after following a woman into her Aspen Pointe apartment, robbing her at knifepoint, and then tracking muddy footprints back to his own home. In spite of his mother warning him to run when the police arrived, he was caught and subsequently pled guilty. His criminal career had centered so closely on Aspen Pointe apartments that several victims and witnesses from the complex were able to positively identify him from a variety of separate incidents.
Two years later, a man knocked on an acquaintance’s Aspen Pointe apartment door and demanded drugs from him at gunpoint. The target’s sister called the police, who surrounded the building. During the ensuing hostage standoff, the gunman raped the sister, and then fell asleep, allowing the police to enter and arrest him.
When a location harbors the illegal drug trade such was alleged in the “hostage standoff incident”, it’s almost always a correlating factor with other crime. Whatever the reason, the crime pattern has continued at Aspen Pointe. Two more years after the hostage standoff, a pair of bodies were found in the woods next to the complex, of a father and son. They are believed to have died there in a murder-suicide.
Yet another two years later, in 2015, the same year as the Bradford Ridge case, the residents of Aspen Pointe were still being freely and brazenly targeted by burglars. One woman reported catching a burglar in the act while up late with her young daughter. Thankfully, the burglar left their apartment without violence when he saw them. He wasn’t bothered enough by the interruption to stop his door-to-door spree of break-ins, however. When he was finally apprehended at a neighboring complex, he attacked and bit the arresting officer.
Security Conditions Do Not Seem to Be Improving for JAMCO’s Residents
The settlement for the murder at Bradford Ridge should have been an overdue wakeup call for JAMCO Properties, leading to improved security at all of their complexes. Was it? Well:
As recently as May 2019, a tenant of JAMCO’s Willow Lake Apartment Homes interrupted a burglar who then fled and wandered the surrounding area holding a stolen shotgun, until he was shot, non-fatally, by police.
Also in May of 2019, JAMCO’s Cascade Glen Apartment Homes complex saw two men draw on each other and fire, leaving one of them dead. The other was never caught. Much like the 2015 murder at Bradford Ridge, this one closely resembled a previous crime at the same location. In June of 2016, two men living at Cascade Glen were shot and hospitalized, one with a wound to the chest, the other to the head. Once again, JAMCO failed to respond and prepare adequately for likely future events.
Over in Decatur, in November of 2017, another car theft, strikingly reminiscent of the one at Bradford Ridge, took place at another JAMCO property — the Village at Wesley Chapel. No one was shot this time, but the thief did make off with victim’s truck, kidnapping her baby brother in the process. When the thief refused to allow her to retrieve her brother, the woman clung to the outside of the vehicle as it sped away, until the thief managed to shake her off. He later abandoned the baby, unharmed, at a nearby convenience store, but was never identified.
This complex too had a history of security problems before the carjacking, but of a different kind. In 2012, two security guards who were supposed to be protecting the Village at Wesley Chapel instead shot and killed an innocent teenager in front of a neighboring residence while impersonating police officers. They later claimed that the 18-year-old new father was “walking toward them aggressively.” The victim was unarmed and on his way to confront a group of teenage girls in a nearby vehicle, who had just arrived at his home to fight his younger sister.
What to Do If Your Apartment Complex Is Not Adequately Protected
Inappropriate behavior by security personnel and failure to respond to similar past crimes are not the only reasons a landlord may be responsible for violent crimes on a property. Your landlord may also be liable for the actions of criminals if those actions were made possible by clear security flaws that the landlord knew about in advance.
Examples of such security flaws include:
Damaged or missing locks
Gates left propped open
Inadequate lighting in common areas
Providing housing to felons and/or known violent criminals
Other than locks on the doors of individual dwellings, there is no universal, agreed-upon standard for how much preemptive security a landlord must provide when no crimes have yet occurred. That said, it’s more than reasonable to expect already installed security systems to be maintained in good working order, especially if they were among the benefits of the complex that were advertised to you before the signing of your lease.
If you’re worried about visible gaps in your building’s security, it’s a good idea to take pictures for your records and express your concerns to your landlord or manager in writing, to ensure that ignorance will not be a viable defense should something happen.
The Stoddard Firm Has Extensive Experience in Landlord Negligent Security
While a property owner’s duty to provide a safe environment is clear under the law, individual cases all have their own unique complexities. Further, many apartment complex owners are experts at muddying the waters in any way possible, and preying on people’s willingness to believe that crime is inevitable.
If you or a loved one have been the victim of a violent crime that could have been foreseen and prevented by JAMCO or another property management company, it’s crucial to have an expert of your own at your side. The passionate, seasoned professionals at The Stoddard firm have years of experience in proving landlord liability in negligent security in ways that both judges and juries can understand and recognize.
We know nothing can bring back a lost family member, erase a life-changing injury, or restore your peace of mind, and we know how frustrating it can be when the direct perpetrator of a crime can’t be found or has no assets with which to make amends. Even so, holding landlords responsible for their negligence can go a long way toward getting your life back on track.
We’ll work with you to establish the foreseeability of the crime, and the concrete ways your landlord failed to provide the necessary security to prevent tragedies like yours, to make sure you get the full compensation you deserve.
Reach out today via our online chat function, or at 678-RESULT, for a completely free consultation on your unique case and how we can help.
Tell us about your concern and request a free, no obligation, confidential legal consultation.
Many people consider it a fact of life that only the rich can afford safety. Those who don’t own their own homes or pay luxury rates for their rentals end up living in areas with higher rates of violent crime, often in buildings lacking basic security measures. When a resident falls victim to a crime, there’s often an attitude of “you get what you pay for,” and an assumption that the landlord c...